What are the best college essay tips you’ve heard directly from admissions counselors?

Great question! A lot of advice from admissions counselors doesn't always make it online, so here are some memorable tips I've received firsthand from info sessions, Q&As, and meetings. These might help you stress less and write more authentically.

One admissions counselor once said, “Write the essay only *you* could write.” This means—the story, details, and reflections should be so personal that no one else could swap their name for yours. For example, a student once wrote about their nightly family ritual of counting the day’s cash at their family laundromat—using this to explore themes of responsibility and community in a way that was vivid and unique to her life.

Another tip: focus on one moment or experience, not your whole life story. Counselors often mention that the best essays zoom in on a specific incident—big or small—that reveals something meaningful about who you are. Someone wrote only about the act of making tamales with their grandmother, letting that slice of life speak volumes about heritage, perseverance, and generational ties.

A Harvard admissions officer shared, “Don’t try to impress us with big words or acedemic language. We want to hear your authentic voice.” Read your essay aloud—if it doesn't sound like you, keep revising.

Something not to do: Many counselors mention that essays about overcoming sports injuries, moving schools, or getting an A in a hard class are extremely common, and unless your perspective is surprisingly fresh, it might not stand out. One example of a unique approach: A student who wrote about a failed salsa recipe that turned into a family disaster, tracing how she learned to laugh at herself and adapt, instead of focusing on bigger, more traditional challenges.

Finally, a surprising tip: Don’t be afraid to be a little quirky or humorous if that fits your personality. An admissions counselor at Tufts said some of their favorite essays make them smile or reveal a playful side. Even a simple anecdote about a failed DIY project can be compelling if it’s told honestly and with personality.

In summary: zero in on a meaningful moment, be as specific as possible, don’t overthink the language, and let your natural voice shine through. That’s the stuff admissions counselors remember!