How important is the college essay in the admissions process?
I'm starting to work on my college applications, and I've heard a ton of different things about the importance of the essay. Some people say it's make-or-break, and others act like it's just an afterthought to your grades and test scores.
I have a pretty solid GPA and decent extracurriculars, but I'm not the most unique person out there. Honestly, I'm stressing about whether my essay could really change my chances. Do colleges really care about it that much, or is it just something they skim over? I want to know how much effort I should be putting into this compared to the rest of my application.
If anyone has advice or stories about how much their essay mattered, I'd really appreciate it. Not sure whether I should spend weeks perfecting it or just try to write something genuine and move on.
I have a pretty solid GPA and decent extracurriculars, but I'm not the most unique person out there. Honestly, I'm stressing about whether my essay could really change my chances. Do colleges really care about it that much, or is it just something they skim over? I want to know how much effort I should be putting into this compared to the rest of my application.
If anyone has advice or stories about how much their essay mattered, I'd really appreciate it. Not sure whether I should spend weeks perfecting it or just try to write something genuine and move on.
6 months ago
•
22 views
Robert Carlson
• 6 months ago
Advisor
Great question! The importance of the college essay in the admissions process can vary depending on the school, but for most selective colleges, the essay is one of the most meaningful parts of your application. Grades and test scores help schools narrow down their applicant pool early on, but the essay is your main opportunity to stand out and show admissions officers aspects of your personality and life story that transcripts don’t reveal.
Think of it this way: a lot of applicants have strong GPAs and impressive activities. The essay is often the first place where your unique voice and perspective shine through. For example, you might be "not the most unique person" in the traditional sense, but sharing a thoughtful story about a small moment of growth, a surprising passion, or a subtle part of your identity can make you memorable. I've worked with a lot of students who got into their top-choice school with lower-than-average numbers; it was their essays that made the difference.
I’d recommend putting a good amount of effort into it—write something genuine and true to you, and give yourself time to revise it. Start early, and consider working with a Sundial admissions advisor if you'd like additional help with brainstorming, outlining, and editing.
Long story short: the essay isn’t everything, but it really does matter—especially if you want to stand out in a competitive pool. Write something true to who you are, revise thoughtfully, and know that your effort WILL be noticed!
Think of it this way: a lot of applicants have strong GPAs and impressive activities. The essay is often the first place where your unique voice and perspective shine through. For example, you might be "not the most unique person" in the traditional sense, but sharing a thoughtful story about a small moment of growth, a surprising passion, or a subtle part of your identity can make you memorable. I've worked with a lot of students who got into their top-choice school with lower-than-average numbers; it was their essays that made the difference.
I’d recommend putting a good amount of effort into it—write something genuine and true to you, and give yourself time to revise it. Start early, and consider working with a Sundial admissions advisor if you'd like additional help with brainstorming, outlining, and editing.
Long story short: the essay isn’t everything, but it really does matter—especially if you want to stand out in a competitive pool. Write something true to who you are, revise thoughtfully, and know that your effort WILL be noticed!
Related Questions
Students also ask…
Which colleges still require the SAT essay for admissions?
Who actually reads our college application essays and how are they evaluated?
Can anyone share strong examples of 'Why are you interested in this college?' essays?
Can someone show a sample 'Why are you interested in this college?' essay?
How should I approach the 'Why do I want to go to college?' essay prompt?
Robert Carlson
New York, NY
Duke University BA; Johns Hopkins MA
Experience
7 years
Rating
4.9 (147 reviews)