Is college essay consulting worth it, or can I just go it alone?
I'm currently a rising senior starting to really stress about my college essays. I've heard a lot about essay consultants and how they help people perfect their essays, but they're so expensive. I'm a decent writer and my school counselors will give some feedback.
Is there a huge difference between writing my essays on my own vs. paying for a consultant? Any stories from people who did or didn't use one? I'd love to know if it's something you actually recommend or if it's mostly hype. I don't want to waste money if I can get the same help elsewhere, but I also want my app to be as strong as possible.
Is there a huge difference between writing my essays on my own vs. paying for a consultant? Any stories from people who did or didn't use one? I'd love to know if it's something you actually recommend or if it's mostly hype. I don't want to waste money if I can get the same help elsewhere, but I also want my app to be as strong as possible.
1 week ago
•
3 views
Roger Lopez
• 1 week ago
Advisor
Great question! First off, it's totally normal to feel this stress—college essays are a big piece of the process.
To answer your question: hiring a college essay consultant can be helpful, but it's absolutely possible to write a compelling essay on your own, especially if you're a strong writer or have access to feedback from teachers or counselors.
Consultants can help brainstorm unique topics, structure your narrative, and avoid common pitfalls, especially if you're struggling to identify what makes you stand out, or if you want deeper, one-on-one guidance. For some students, that boost in confidence alone is worth the investment. For example, I’ve seen students who had solid drafts but couldn’t figure out how to stand out until a consultant prompted them to dig deeper about a quirky family tradition or an unexpected failure. Sometimes that extra perspective is what turns a good essay into a great one.
That said, plenty of students write fantastic essays without consultants. If you leverage your school’s resources, ask trusted teachers or adults for honest feedback, and carefully edit using resources like writing centers or even peer review forums, you can absolutely craft an essay that represents your voice. It may take more drafts and more initiative, but many successful applicants go this route and save the money.
If you're worried about missing out on nuanced feedback (like, “Does this topic sound cliché?” or "Does this anecdote really show who I am?"), consider getting feedback from multiple people. Sometimes, peers can notice things you don’t, and teachers can help with clarity and grammar. A small study group or writing circle can replicate some of the consultant’s benefits.
If money is a concern, you’re not at a disadvantage. Just approach your essay thoughtfully and use the resources you have. And, if you find yourself stuck later, remember that one-time feedback services or essay review programs can be a more budget-friendly alternative to full consulting packages.
So to sum up: consultants aren’t a necessity. They’re a tool, but not the only path to a strong essay. If you’re organized, open to honest feedback, and willing to revise, you can absolutely succeed on your own.
Wishing you the best as you start your college essay journey!
To answer your question: hiring a college essay consultant can be helpful, but it's absolutely possible to write a compelling essay on your own, especially if you're a strong writer or have access to feedback from teachers or counselors.
Consultants can help brainstorm unique topics, structure your narrative, and avoid common pitfalls, especially if you're struggling to identify what makes you stand out, or if you want deeper, one-on-one guidance. For some students, that boost in confidence alone is worth the investment. For example, I’ve seen students who had solid drafts but couldn’t figure out how to stand out until a consultant prompted them to dig deeper about a quirky family tradition or an unexpected failure. Sometimes that extra perspective is what turns a good essay into a great one.
That said, plenty of students write fantastic essays without consultants. If you leverage your school’s resources, ask trusted teachers or adults for honest feedback, and carefully edit using resources like writing centers or even peer review forums, you can absolutely craft an essay that represents your voice. It may take more drafts and more initiative, but many successful applicants go this route and save the money.
If you're worried about missing out on nuanced feedback (like, “Does this topic sound cliché?” or "Does this anecdote really show who I am?"), consider getting feedback from multiple people. Sometimes, peers can notice things you don’t, and teachers can help with clarity and grammar. A small study group or writing circle can replicate some of the consultant’s benefits.
If money is a concern, you’re not at a disadvantage. Just approach your essay thoughtfully and use the resources you have. And, if you find yourself stuck later, remember that one-time feedback services or essay review programs can be a more budget-friendly alternative to full consulting packages.
So to sum up: consultants aren’t a necessity. They’re a tool, but not the only path to a strong essay. If you’re organized, open to honest feedback, and willing to revise, you can absolutely succeed on your own.
Wishing you the best as you start your college essay journey!
Roger Lopez
Chicago, Illinois
Yale University BA, Political Science | Northwestern Kellogg School of Management, MBA Candidate |
Experience
4 years