Can anyone share examples of Hamilton College essays that worked?

Hamilton College is well-known for emphasizing strong, authentic writing in their application essays, so it’s smart to look for inspiration. While it’s not allowed to share full essays from previous successful applicants due to privacy and copyright concerns, you can definitely learn a lot from summaries and examples of approaches that have worked.

For the community prompt, students who stood out often focused on a very specific and meaningful interaction rather than a broad group or experience. Instead of writing generally about their school or sports team, a student might have written about their Saturday mornings volunteering at a local food pantry, focusing on a single moment when they connected with someone from a different background. For example, one applicant described translating for a new family during their first visit, showing both empathy and the skills gained from bridging communities. This not only reflected their involvement, but also revealed their values and how they contribute at a personal level.

Regarding the identity prompt, successful essays usually go beyond surface-level traits. For instance, an applicant wrote about their passion for creating zines that addressed mental health in their high school, describing how their personal experiences led them to build a small but supportive community. They illustrated growth by mentioning moments where they felt unsure, but found confidence through helping others express themselves creatively.

Hamilton essays tend to resonate when they’re written with clear, direct language and vivid details. It’s important to show, not just tell, how an experience shaped you. Focus on small anecdotes, moments of change, or specific challenges faced. Avoid trying to impress with overly academic language—Hamilton values a distinctive, honest voice that feels personal and reflective.

When reviewing your drafts, ask yourself: Is this story something only I could tell? Have I included details that help the reader see, hear, or feel the experience? Sometimes, even an ordinary moment, told with color and honesty, is more memorable than an extraordinary achievement described generically.

If you’re feeling stuck, try writing about a single conversation, a moment when something clicked, or a time you took a risk. Hamilton offers some advice on their admissions blog, where they occasionally share essay tips and snippets of standout responses (look for their "Writing What Matters" posts).

Above all, prioritize authenticity and clarity in your essay. Admissions readers are looking to understand you beyond your grades and scores, so let your unique perspective shine through. Good luck!