Syracuse University vs. UMass Amherst: Which Is More Test-Optional-Friendly?

Both Syracuse and UMass Amherst are viable test-optional choices, and neither school says applicants are disadvantaged simply for withholding SAT or ACT scores. UMass Amherst is likely the slightly more straightforward option for a student whose application will be built around grades, course rigor, and sustained activities, because its test-optional approach is broadly established across undergraduate admission.

At UMass Amherst, applying without scores means the admissions office will put greater weight on the transcript: performance over several years, the level of courses available to you, and grades in subjects connected to your intended major. Strong teacher recommendations, meaningful extracurricular involvement, and a clear application narrative can reinforce those academic strengths.

Syracuse similarly reviews non-submitters through the rest of the application, including academic preparation, activities, recommendations, and writing. Portfolio, audition, or program-specific materials, where applicable, can matter far more than a missing test score.

Apply test-optional to either institution if your scores are meaningfully below what your transcript suggests about your readiness. For UMass Amherst, pay close attention to having a rigorous senior schedule and strong grades in prerequisite subjects for your major. For Syracuse, make the essays and activity descriptions concrete enough to show what you would contribute to the particular academic community you are applying to.