How does the undergraduate experience at Arizona State compare to Colby College?

I’m trying to understand what day-to-day life feels like for undergrads at these two schools, beyond just rankings and stats. I know ASU is much larger and Colby is a small liberal arts college, but I’m having trouble picturing how that changes classes, campus culture, and the overall student experience.

I’m mainly looking for a clear comparison of what it’s like to actually attend each one as an undergraduate.
0 views
College is too important to leave to AI
Life-changing decisions deserve guidance from an expert
A real advisor gets to know you, brings experience from helping other students, and helps you make choices with confidence.
Sundial AI
AI-assisted guidance informed by the expertise of Sundial's admissions advisors
Colby offers the more intentionally undergraduate-centered experience, while Arizona State gives you far more scale, choice, and big-university energy. At Colby, nearly everything on campus is built around undergrads because it is a small liberal arts college with no large graduate-school presence shaping classes or resources. At ASU, the day-to-day feel is much broader and less intimate, with multiple campuses, a huge student population, and many different academic and social subcultures existing at once.

In the classroom, Colby is more likely to feel discussion-based, personal, and professor-driven from the start. Small classes are a core part of the model, and faculty interaction tends to be built into normal academic life rather than something you have to chase. ASU has plenty of excellent faculty and opportunities too, but the experience varies much more by major, campus, and course level. Intro classes can feel large and more structured, and students often need to be proactive about office hours, research, and building close academic relationships.

Socially, ASU feels like a full-scale public university ecosystem. There are major sports, a wide range of student organizations, a more visible party scene, and a lot happening at any given time, especially in and around Tempe. That can be exciting, but it also means more independence and less of a single shared campus culture. Colby is quieter, more residential, and more enclosed, with a stronger sense that the student body is living in the same world together day to day. Because Waterville is smaller and the campus is more self-contained, a lot of social life revolves around campus events, residence halls, outdoor activities, and close friend groups.

The physical setting changes the experience quite a bit too. ASU is embedded in a large metro area, so internships, off-campus food, entertainment, and city access are much more immediate. Colby has a more traditional residential-college rhythm, with a scenic campus in central Maine and a pace that feels more removed and immersive. One environment gives you constant external options; the other tends to pull students more tightly into campus life.

Advising and opportunities also work differently. At ASU, the menu is enormous, from majors and minors to research labs, honors programs, and professional pathways, but students often have to navigate that complexity themselves. At Colby, the range is naturally smaller, yet access can feel more straightforward because there are fewer layers and less competition for faculty attention in everyday undergraduate life.
Have questions about the admissions process?
Start working with a Sundial advisor today!

Comments & Questions (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to ask a question or share your thoughts!

Start the conversation

Have a follow-up question or want to share your experience? Leave a comment below.

College is too important to leave to AI
Life-changing decisions deserve guidance from an expert
A real advisor gets to know you, brings experience from helping other students, and helps you make choices with confidence.
Have questions about the admissions process?
Start working with a Sundial advisor today!