What makes a personal college essay stand out from the rest?
I've been working on my Common App essay for a few weeks now, but I feel like I'm just going in circles. I keep hearing that the best personal essays are unique and really show your personality, but that's easier said than done!
I'm looking for advice on what makes for a truly memorable college essay. Is it all about the story you choose, or is there something special about how you write it? I'd love to hear examples (not whole essays, just what they were about) or insights from people who've already gone through this process.
If you wrote something super personal, did you ever feel uncomfortable submitting it or worry it was too much? How do you decide just how honest or vulnerable to be with admissions officers?
I'm looking for advice on what makes for a truly memorable college essay. Is it all about the story you choose, or is there something special about how you write it? I'd love to hear examples (not whole essays, just what they were about) or insights from people who've already gone through this process.
If you wrote something super personal, did you ever feel uncomfortable submitting it or worry it was too much? How do you decide just how honest or vulnerable to be with admissions officers?
4 months ago
•
29 views
Camille Luong
• 4 months ago
Advisor
A personal college essay stands out when it reveals something deeply authentic about you that goes beyond your resume or transcript.
The story you pick is important, but what really grabs an admissions officer is your reflection—why this story matters to you, how it shaped your outlook, and what it shows about your values or growth. Your personality should come through in both the topic and the way you write: your voice, your quirks, your take on the world.
Specificity is key. Admissions officers read thousands of essays about "hard work," "learning from failures," or "helping others." To avoid blending in, focus on a moment or detail that's distinctly yours. For example, instead of a classic essay on moving to a new school, one student wrote about the ritual of making their grandmother’s unique dumpling recipe as a way to connect to their heritage and adapt to change. Another described a single awkward conversation with a sibling that sparked a love for linguistics. The uniqueness comes from your genuine perspective and the details you choose to highlight.
Writing style matters, but you don't need to be a literary genius. What helps is clarity, honest self-expression, and sometimes a touch of humor or humility. If a passage makes your friends or family say, “This sounds just like you,” you’re on the right track.
On vulnerability: It's normal to wonder if you’re sharing too much. The best essays often include some risk or vulnerability, as long as you’re comfortable and the content is relevant. For instance, students have written about personal struggles, identity questions, even moments of failure—but always with a forward-looking attitude, showing what they learned or how they grew. If you’re unsure, ask yourself: am I sharing this because it’s core to who I am, or just to shock or impress?
Ultimately, standout essays reflect real, lived experience and insight. Don’t just try to impress; aim to connect. If you’re honest and introspective, even a simple story can be powerful. Sometimes it helps to read essays from admitted students—not to copy, but to see how varied and deeply personal great essays can be.
The story you pick is important, but what really grabs an admissions officer is your reflection—why this story matters to you, how it shaped your outlook, and what it shows about your values or growth. Your personality should come through in both the topic and the way you write: your voice, your quirks, your take on the world.
Specificity is key. Admissions officers read thousands of essays about "hard work," "learning from failures," or "helping others." To avoid blending in, focus on a moment or detail that's distinctly yours. For example, instead of a classic essay on moving to a new school, one student wrote about the ritual of making their grandmother’s unique dumpling recipe as a way to connect to their heritage and adapt to change. Another described a single awkward conversation with a sibling that sparked a love for linguistics. The uniqueness comes from your genuine perspective and the details you choose to highlight.
Writing style matters, but you don't need to be a literary genius. What helps is clarity, honest self-expression, and sometimes a touch of humor or humility. If a passage makes your friends or family say, “This sounds just like you,” you’re on the right track.
On vulnerability: It's normal to wonder if you’re sharing too much. The best essays often include some risk or vulnerability, as long as you’re comfortable and the content is relevant. For instance, students have written about personal struggles, identity questions, even moments of failure—but always with a forward-looking attitude, showing what they learned or how they grew. If you’re unsure, ask yourself: am I sharing this because it’s core to who I am, or just to shock or impress?
Ultimately, standout essays reflect real, lived experience and insight. Don’t just try to impress; aim to connect. If you’re honest and introspective, even a simple story can be powerful. Sometimes it helps to read essays from admitted students—not to copy, but to see how varied and deeply personal great essays can be.
Related Questions
Students also ask…
What makes a college essay stand out as the 'greatest' ever written?
What makes a college admissions essay stand out as 'good'?
What makes a college essay stand out to admissions officers?
What should I write about in my college application essay if I'm not sure what makes me stand out?
Which colleges still require the SAT essay for admissions?
Camille Luong
Nomadic
Stanford University, BAH in Urban Studies
Experience
5 years
Rating
5.0 (5 reviews)