Should I submit the optional college essay or skip it?

It’s definitely common for students to debate whether to write the optional college essay, especially when application season is packed with writing. While 'optional' technically means you aren’t required to submit it, in practice, submitting the essay is often considered a positive step.

Providing an optional essay gives you an extra opportunity to share more about yourself, your interests, or your background. Colleges look for reasons to admit students, and a thoughtful optional essay can give additional context or dimension to your application that might not come across in your main essay, résumé, or activities list. For example, if the optional prompt asks about your commitment to diversity, community, or overcoming obstacles, including an essay—even if your answer isn’t dramatic or revolutionary—can show reflection and maturity.

However, quality definitely counts more than quantity. If you’re spread thin, you should prioritize required essays and supplements for your top-choice schools. Don’t rush to fill in an optional essay if your response would feel generic or forced. Submitting an uninspired or superficial essay can actually work against you. If you don’t have a strong or relevant answer, it’s better to skip than submit something lackluster.

Here’s an example: Suppose the optional prompt asks if there’s anything important you want the admissions office to know about you. If you have a context—like a family hardship that affected your grades, or a meaningful project not covered elsewhere—this is your chance to share it. If you don’t, focus energy where it matters most. But if you do feel you have a perspective or story to share—even if it’s small but meaningful to you—it’s usually worth submitting.

In summary, an optional essay can help your application, especially at selective schools, but only if you have something thoughtful and personal to say. If you’re unsure, read the prompt carefully and ask yourself if your answer will add new information or a compelling dimension to your application. If yes, go for it! If not, use that time to polish the essays that will really make or break your application.