What are some good personal essay prompts for college applications?

It’s totally normal to feel overwhelmed by all the choices when it comes to essay prompts, especially since both the Common App and supplemental essays offer so many different directions. One thing to keep in mind is that the best prompt for you is usually the one that lets you share something deeply personal, specific, and meaningful—rather than trying to guess what will impress admissions committees the most.

Some students gravitate toward the "Describe a challenge or setback and how you responded" prompt (Common App #2), but unless you have a unique take or a less-common experience, this one can get generic fast. Instead, many find success with prompts like "Discuss an accomplishment, event, or realization that sparked a period of personal growth" (Common App #5) or the "background, identity, interest, or talent" prompt (Common App #1). These allow for more flexibility and personal details.

If you’re a creative thinker, prompts that ask about your passions or a problem you’d like to solve can open the door to telling a story in your own voice.

If a school offers a quirky question—like "What’s so odd about odd numbers?" from the University of Chicago—some students go for it if the humor and open-endedness matches their personality. However, don’t force yourself into the wackiest choice just for the sake of standing out. The essay that feels more "you," even if it seems less showy, is usually stronger.

As you brainstorm, jot down stories, moments, or passions that have genuinely shaped you—even if at first they don’t seem "college essay worthy." The right prompt is one that frames a story you actually want to tell. Try a few drafts responding to different prompts and see which feels the most engaging and authentic. Don’t be afraid to revise or switch prompts later if your best story emerges a little unexpectedly.