How can I make my Ivy League college essay stand out?
I've started drafting my Common App essay, but I'm nervous that it won't be unique enough for the Ivy League schools I'm aiming for (Princeton and Yale are my top choices).
I guess everyone applying has excellent grades and extracurriculars, so I'm worried the essay is my only real chance to show something different. For those who got into an Ivy, what sorts of topics did you write about? Did you take a big risk, or keep it more traditional? If anyone has tips on ways to make my essay actually stand out instead of blending in, I would really appreciate it.
Also, is it true that the essay can make or break your application, or is that just what people say to freak us out?
I guess everyone applying has excellent grades and extracurriculars, so I'm worried the essay is my only real chance to show something different. For those who got into an Ivy, what sorts of topics did you write about? Did you take a big risk, or keep it more traditional? If anyone has tips on ways to make my essay actually stand out instead of blending in, I would really appreciate it.
Also, is it true that the essay can make or break your application, or is that just what people say to freak us out?
6 months ago
•
19 views
Roger Lopez
• 6 months ago
Advisor
Your concern is really common—most Ivy League applicants have impressive stats and activities, so the essay is often where you can differentiate yourself beyond just a resume.
When it comes to standing out, specificity and authenticity are more important than trying to be wildly unique or shocking. The best essays usually focus on a distinctive perspective, a small but meaningful story, or a moment of genuine reflection. Admissions readers have seen countless essays about leadership, overcoming academic challenges, or winning championships. But what they rarely see are deeply personal moments, odd quirks, or a day-in-the-life rendered with vivid detail.
If you have a classic topic you care about (let’s say, playing violin), drill down to one incredibly specific experience: the moment before a solo when a string snapped, or a quiet practice session with your grandmother that changed how you understood music. Focusing on a single event or unexpected angle usually makes the essay far more memorable.
Being vulnerable can be powerful, but only if it’s comfortable for you and fits naturally. You don’t need to manufacture drama—sometimes, a thoughtful exploration of a seemingly ordinary moment can say much more about you than a generic “big” accomplishment.
As for the impact of the essay: while it isn’t literally a make-or-break for everyone, strong essays can absolutely sway decisions, especially at hyper-selective places like Princeton and Yale where almost all serious applicants are qualified. If admissions officers are deciding between applicants with similar achievements, a memorable essay can tip the balance. Focus on crafting a snapshot only you could give—one that reveals your voice and values.
Ask those who know you best to read early drafts and tell you if the essay ‘feels’ like you. If someone else could put their name at the top and the story would still make sense, revise again until it’s unmistakably yours.
Good luck—you really do have a chance to inspire, surprise, or move the reader if you write honestly from your own lived experience.
When it comes to standing out, specificity and authenticity are more important than trying to be wildly unique or shocking. The best essays usually focus on a distinctive perspective, a small but meaningful story, or a moment of genuine reflection. Admissions readers have seen countless essays about leadership, overcoming academic challenges, or winning championships. But what they rarely see are deeply personal moments, odd quirks, or a day-in-the-life rendered with vivid detail.
If you have a classic topic you care about (let’s say, playing violin), drill down to one incredibly specific experience: the moment before a solo when a string snapped, or a quiet practice session with your grandmother that changed how you understood music. Focusing on a single event or unexpected angle usually makes the essay far more memorable.
Being vulnerable can be powerful, but only if it’s comfortable for you and fits naturally. You don’t need to manufacture drama—sometimes, a thoughtful exploration of a seemingly ordinary moment can say much more about you than a generic “big” accomplishment.
As for the impact of the essay: while it isn’t literally a make-or-break for everyone, strong essays can absolutely sway decisions, especially at hyper-selective places like Princeton and Yale where almost all serious applicants are qualified. If admissions officers are deciding between applicants with similar achievements, a memorable essay can tip the balance. Focus on crafting a snapshot only you could give—one that reveals your voice and values.
Ask those who know you best to read early drafts and tell you if the essay ‘feels’ like you. If someone else could put their name at the top and the story would still make sense, revise again until it’s unmistakably yours.
Good luck—you really do have a chance to inspire, surprise, or move the reader if you write honestly from your own lived experience.
Related Questions
Students also ask…
Roger Lopez
Chicago, Illinois
Yale University BA, Political Science | Northwestern Kellogg School of Management, MBA Candidate |
Experience
4 years