Robbie Herbst
4.9(58 reviews)
Essay Review
4.9(58 reviews)
Robbie Herbst
About
Hi! I'm a violinist, writer, and editor, and for the last nine years I've worked with students applying to college, medical school, law school, and other professional degrees. I love working with students to develop essays that share their stories in compelling and unique ways.

I'm fortunate to have a varied career that adds a nuanced perspective to my application work. I'm the Assistant Principal Second Violin with the Elgin Symphony Orchestra, and I freelance as a violinist in the Chicago area. As a writer, I publish short fiction in journals including Gulf Coast, The Rumpus, and the Masters Review. I've worked as an editor for many years and in many contexts including founding Dartmouth's literary magazine, Humbug.

In the 2023-2024 application cycle, my students were accepted to Columbia, Cornell, Brown, Duke, University of Chicago, USC, NYU, UNC Chapel Hill, Vanderbilt, Bates, Northwestern, UC Berkeley, UCLA and many others!
Chicago
9 years of experience
πŸŽ“
Dartmouth College – BA | History and Music
University of Colorado Boulder – MM | Violin Performance
University of Colorado Boulder – MM | Artist Diploma
How I work
I've worked with hundreds of students and read thousands of essays. I know what works and what doesn't. I take pride in helping students discover the unique thing that they have to say and expressing it in clear and compelling language.

*If you come from a working class family, I encourage you to reach out about a free consultation! If so, please mention it in your request.*

I can work with you at any stage of the writing process, from brainstorming all the way through intensive copy and line edits. I've worked with students interested in any and all fields, from engineering, to business, to humanities, to performing arts. I've worked with veterans, transfer students, international students coming to the U.S., and older adults who are returning to school. In recent years, I've focused particularly on students applying to BS/MD programs as well as conventional med school applications. As a professional violinist, I have unique insight into students who are both talented artists and academically driven. I love working with high schoolers who are trying to build a life that combines those two things. It was an important part of my own journey, but it's not always easy to figure out on your own! Whatever your story is, I'd like to hear it and help you achieve your goals.

Here are some selected reviews from students:

"stupendous review. felt like my third eye was opened. thanks so much!"

"Robbie provides detailed advice and great insights on how to improve your essays. His comments helped me take my essay to another level and gave me a clear direction to work towards. He's great to work with and super flexible. Thank you Robbie! "

"You are my savior. Thank you so much!"

"Robbie's feedback is incredible. He really looks into what areas of your essay need refinement, and provides great insight as to what you could add on, specify, etc. Highly Recommend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
I’ve helped students get accepted to…
Boston College
Boston University
Bowdoin College
Brown University
Carnegie Mellon University
Case Western Reserve University
Chapman University
Clemson University
College of William & Mary
Columbia University
Cornell University
Dartmouth College
Duke University
Emory University
Georgetown University
Harvard University
Johns Hopkins University
New York University
Northeastern University
Northwestern University
Rice University
Tufts University
Tulane University
University of Chicago
University of Michigan
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
University of Southern California
University of Texas at Austin
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Vanderbilt University
Yale University
Services
Advising sessions
Essay Review and Zoom Consultation
$175Β | 60 min
Essay reviews, interview prep, list building, activities write ups - you name it, we can do it! If you would like to schedule a time to have an open-ended consultation, please let me know if advance what you would like to cover so I can prepare. Robbie
Book session
Essay review
Essay Review
$40 + 20Β’ per word
Detailed suggestions (comments and line edits) on how the essay can improve. I'll answer whatever specific questions you have - don't ask me to give it a grade out of 10!
Submit essay
UC PIQs Package
$230
I'll review and edit all four UC PIQs. NOTE - if you submit fewer than four, it's the same price (hence the 'package' of it all). If you submit more than four, I'll only read the first four in the document.
Submit essay
Reviews
Anastasia M
5
| 6 months ago
Amazing feedback. A lot of comments (which is really good as it really improves the essay), and it's great how you told me the ways to solve my problems.
5
| 9 months ago
Very helpful with concrete feedback.
5
| Over 1 year ago
4
| Over 1 year ago
Good feedback
5
| Over 1 year ago
Thank you so much for the time and effort you put into reading my essay! I really want this essay to be great and your comments/suggestions really help me with that.
Fun facts
⭐
Hobbies
Rock Climbing, Photography, Reading
πŸ—£
Favorite piece of advice
Questions get the answers they deserve
🎬
Favorite movie
Waking Life
πŸ“–
Favorite author
Virginia Woolf
πŸŽ“
Favorite classes in school
History
🎧
Favorite album
Abbey Road
πŸ§‘πŸΌβ€πŸ’Ό
First job
Barista